September 5, 2026 · 6 min read · Security Tips

Keypad Door Locks vs. Traditional Deadbolts

Keypads are convenient. Deadbolts are simple. Which is better depends on how your household actually uses the door.

Keypad deadbolt next to a traditional keyed deadbolt

Keypad and smart locks have become one of the most popular upgrades we install. They're not right for every door, though. Here's how the two compare.

Convenience

Keypads win here. No keys to lose, codes for family, dog walkers, or contractors, and the ability to delete a code instantly. Many smart models also let you lock the door from your phone.

Security

A well-made keypad deadbolt and a well-made keyed deadbolt both use a solid bolt. The bigger security factor is usually the door, frame, and strike plate, not whether you use a code or a key.

Illinois winters

Cold weather drains batteries faster. Choose a model with a low-battery warning, and replace batteries before winter. Most keypads also have a backup key or external battery terminal.

Cost

Keypad and smart locks cost more than standard deadbolts, and they need batteries. A traditional deadbolt has no electronics to fail.

Which should you choose?

  • Busy household, frequent visitors, or kids coming home alone: keypad or smart lock.
  • Rarely used door or a detached building: traditional deadbolt.
  • Rental property: keypad, so codes can change between tenants.

Thinking about a keypad lock? Call and we'll help you pick a model that fits your door.

Call (815) 446-1440

Need a locksmith today?

Call Same Day Locksmith or request service online. We travel to you in Crest Hill and nearby communities.

Service hours: 7:00 AM – 11:00 PM, every day. Illinois Locksmith License No. 191.000919.